Pyatcast

Category: Jamin Hubner

  • Rebuttal to Hubner’s Response to DeYoung

    Jamin Hubner has posted a response to Kevin DeYoung on the topic Baptism and the covenant. Jamin quote KDY as stating: “If circumcision was for Abraham a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith, then we cannot say the cutting away of the flesh was simply an ethnic identity marker or a sign…

  • Hubner’s Recommended Reading

    My friend Jamin Hubner has posted a list of books (from “both sides”) regarding, in his terms, “Economics and Christian Zionism.”  Feel free to check out the list.  He makes one remark that I’ll address and let the rest pass: “they will at least pause when Tur and Hays’ [sic] essentially point a finger and…

  • A Trivium of Responses to Jamin

    Let’s tackle Jamin’s recent post in three parts, which we will style rhetoric, grammar, and logic.  Those familiar with classical education will catch the allusion.   The labels don’t perfectly fit, but we’ll shoe-horn the arguments into those labels.  We’ll also take them out of the traditional order, addressing Jamin’s rhetoric first (but immediately I will…

  • Maybe Hubner Needs to Look Up "Shill" in a Dictionary

    Jamin Hubner responds to my recent post by writing: Turretinfan criticizes a recent post, saying, “ using a source that is a shill for Hamas is still using a bad source.” It seems Tur is suggesting that because a source is used as a Hamas shill, than in and of itself means the source is bad.…

  • Hubner Compares Self to O. Palmer Robertson

    Evidently, Jamin Hubner and O. Palmer Robertson share a similar view regarding Israel on some points.  Hubner seems to think that consistency demands that if he (Hubner) is a “dupe for the jihadists” and is “supporting Arabs with unsound arguments,” then the same must be true of Robertson. There’s a fundamental flaw in Hubner’s reasoning. …

  • Responding to Ryrie regarding John Edwards and Dispensations

    Someone wrote in to Jamin Hubner the following question: In Ryrie’s book he mentions the dispensational scheme that Jonathan Edwards [sic] (not that Edwards was necessarily a dispensationalist) put forth in his work “A Compleat History or Survey of All the Dispensations”. Would this not pre-date Darby? As I have not read this work by…

  • TurretinFan’s Criticism "May Be True" Per Hubner

    Jamin Hubner has posted a response to my post that criticized his unsound argument.  His post is something of a goulash of various points, from which I’ve extracted the parts seemingly related to my post. He writes: The last few posts on this blog have generated a flurry of responses. But unfortunately, very little is…

  • Supporting the Arabs with Unsound Arguments

    Suppose someone argues this: The first is McMahon-Hussein Correspondence, which promised that the Arabs would have their own state in Palestine. This promise was given in hopes of gaining Arab support for the British war efforts against Turkey. The British High Commissioner Sir Henry McMahon promised the following to the Arabs (Oct 24, 1915) in…

  • Reviewing a Blog Exchange Between Hays and Hubner

    I’ve been watching, with some sadness, a blog exchange between two guys with whom I’m on good terms. I thought I’d post my thoughts on the exchange here for what it’s worth. It’s a long post and probably only of interest to me, the two guys, and a few of our mutual friends. Nevertheless, I…

  • Genesis and Theistic Evolution

    I recently appeared as a guest on Jamin Hubner’s Provocative Microphone discussing Genesis and Theistic Evolution (link to mp3). The first portion of the podcast is a discussion between the host and me and the second half is the host’s thoughts on the topic. -TurretinFan To God be the Glory!